Skip to main content

Eggnog Pie

4.2

(5)

Two slices of eggnog pie on dessert plates.
Photo by Joseph De Leo, Prop Styling by Anne Eastman, Food Styling by Rebecca Jurkevich

This eggnog pie recipe appeared as a part of Gourmet’s 1975 Thanksgiving menu, alongside a classic pumpkin pie. Made with both rum and brandy, it’s a boozy dessert that you'll want to make again for Christmas and New Year's Eve.

This recipe is a part of our ‘70s-themed vintage Thanksgiving menu.

Recipe information

  • Total Time

    2 hours

Ingredients

2½ cups finely ground pecans
⅔ cup sugar, divided
½ cup (1 stick) butter, melted
1½ tablespoons gelatin
3 tablespoons brandy
4 eggs, separated
1 cup scalded milk, plus ⅓ cup cold milk
¼ cup plus 1 tablespoon dark rum
1½ teaspoons vanilla
1¾ cups heavy cream, ¾ cup lightly whipped
2 to 3 tablespoons sifted confectioners’ sugar
Semisweet chocolate, shaved (for serving)

Preparation

  1. Step 1

    In a bowl, blend 2½ cups finely ground pecans, ⅓ cup sugar, and ½ cup (1 stick) butter, melted, transfer the mixture to a 9½-inch pie plate, and form it into a shell, pressing it firmly into the plate. Chill the shell for 30 minutes.

    Step 2

    Bake pie shell in a preheated moderately hot oven (375°F) for 15 minutes, or until it is lightly browned, and let it cool completely.

    Step 3

    In a small bowl, sprinkle 1½ tablespoons gelatin over ⅓ cup cold milk to soften for 10 minutes.

    Step 4

    In a bowl, beat 4 egg yolks with remaining ⅓ cup sugar until they form a ribbon when the beater is lifted and add 1 cup scalded milk in a stream, stirring. Pour the mixture into a heavy saucepan and cook it over moderately low heat, stirring, until it is thick enough to coat the spoon, but do not let it boil. Remove the pan from the heat and stir in the softened gelatin, 3 tablespoons brandy, ¼ cup dark rum, and 1½ teaspoons vanilla. Transfer the custard to a bowl set over a larger bowl of ice and let it cool, stirring occasionally, but do not let it set.

    Step 5

    In a large bowl, beat 4 egg whites with a pinch of salt until they hold stiff peaks, fold in ¾ cup heavy cream, lightly whipped, and fold in the custard. Transfer enough of the filling to the prepared shell to fill the shell to the top and chill the pie for 20 minutes, or until the filling is set.

    Step 6

    In another bowl, whip 1 cup heavy cream with 2 to 3 tablespoons sifted confectioners’ sugar and 1 tablespoon dark rum and spread the cream over the pie, mounding it slightly and reserving a small amount. Pipe the reserved cream decoratively around the edge of the pie and decorate the center and sides with chocolate shavings. Sprinkle bits of shaved chocolate over the cream and chill the pie. Remove the pie from the refrigerator at least 30 minutes before serving.

See Related Recipes and Cooking Tips

Read More
Make these cookies for an after-school snack, midday treat, or gift for friends and neighbors.
With a buttery bourbon glaze, this Gourmet legend requires just four ingredients.
These six-ingredient cookies are crisp, golden, and just so happen to be gluten-free.
With a crisp crust and fruity filling, pineapple pie is a Philippine bakeshop specialty.
These brownies feature a delightful combo of warm spices, black tea, and strong coffee.
A plant-based take on a retro Southern dessert.
With the sweet and nutty flavor of ube, these cookies taste like they’ve been dunked into a glass of milk.
Need an elegant dinner party dessert? A quick tea cake? A vacation birthday bake? This chocolaty wonder fits every bill.